The London club might have accepted a draw in advance versus a Chelsea team that have risen as unexpected contenders in recent weeks – and especially when they discovered they had to compete missing William Saliba, who injured himself in practice on Saturday.
It was a different story when the game turned in the 38th minute, with the home side left with 10 men after the midfielder's X-rated challenge on the Arsenal player. It was a type of foul that made you wince upon each replay, with the temporary forward lucky to emerge unscathed.
This marked the team's sixth red card of the season in all competitions – not including the one for the manager, the boss, in the victory over the Reds in last month. Now the visitors had to be thinking about a win; a outcome to secure a significant lead at the summit of the table.
Except it failed to materialize as planned. Chelsea had been in fire-breathing mood at the outset. Maybe it was a reason for why Caicedo transgressed so severely. And they shook their opponents when Trevoh Chalobah headed in a header from a the captain's set-piece at the beginning of the second period.
The away side had to react and they succeeded. It was Merino who netted the leveler, a tribute to his own persistence as much as anything else. And it was he towards the conclusion who did almost snatch the win, his low shot well saved by the goalkeeper. The Chelsea shot-stopper jumped up to save courageously on the rebound from the Arsenal substitute, Viktor Gyökeres.
Thus the team left with a point. It might have been better had the defender not taken an high cross away from Gyökeres at the final moment but no one could say that it was not a just outcome. And a pulsating match.
Who would have predicted it as a top-of-the-table battle at the end of September? That was when the Blues had just been defeated at home to Brighton to sit mid-table and the rumblings of discontent were noticeable. The upturn in their fortunes was showcased by the European defeat of Barcelona last Tuesday and the Saliba news had to be a advantage for them.
The word from Arsenal was that the issue is not too serious but it was significant. With another defender already absent, it meant an tough challenge for the young player and Piero Hincapié in the centre of the team's backline.
It was a derby with lots of snarl and it was only eight minutes in when the winger could be seen instructing Timber to stay concentrated; he pointed at his own temples to make the point. Timber had been bundled over by Caicedo and by then we had seen Mikel Arteta’s first eruption after a Marc Cucurella foul on Saka and the first yellow card – Martín Zubimendi on the captain. There would be more. Several of the Arsenal back four were in the book by the break, one player the exception.
It was always going to be a difficult occasion for the official, Anthony Taylor, though he was a controversial figure on one level. Both sets of supporters regard him as a antagonist. Or phrases to that meaning. There were other descriptions expressed about him at various times.
The referee had no option over the big call of the match, particularly when it was recommended by the VAR, John Brooks, that he ought to review at the player's challenge on Merino. It was elevated and risky, a potential serious injury, the example of over-aggression. He did lose footing. It was, nonetheless, a poor challenge.
Up until that point, Chelsea had shaded it. They overflowed with energy and they created a few chances, the biggest one for Estêvão Willian on the first half. It was a poor clearance by the defender after a winger's delivery. The player shot over. Just before, Declan Rice had been required to extend into a crucial intervention on Neto. A shortly after, the forward paused after a error by his teammate. He ought to have taken the chance.
It said everything that the first half concluded with the midfielder appearing to swing an arm at the defender, causing him to be on the ground as the squad headed for the tunnel. Arsenal wanted to regroup, to determine how to use their advantage. The winger had nearly scored in the early stages after a smooth touch and assist from the playmaker while Gabriel Martinelli tested Sánchez just before the break.
Surprisingly Chelsea who started quickly of the gate upon the restart. From a James free-kick, João Pedro made the goalkeeper to push wide. From the corner, Chalobah rose above the midfielder to redirect for the back post. To pure joy from fans, the ball found the net.
The coach did not introduce negative substitutions after the dismissal. He stuck with attacking players and a striker. That said, it helped to have James performing like multiple players in midfield. The skipper was immense; a constantly influential presence and creative, too. Some of his distribution was of the top quality.
The visitors' equaliser had not been expected. The star, however, is consistently able of creating chances from nowhere. He attacked Cucurella, who had been cautioned for fouling him in the early phase and, when the winger checked inside, his cross was on the money. The team had a numerical advantage at the far post. Merino rose imperiously.
There was a change in momentum after the player's goal. The manager had introduced the captain and the former Chelsea winger the substitute just before it. He also put Gyökeres on and they pushed. They came to dominate in possession and they had the chances for 2-1. The home side stood strong.